Can't change icon

I set up my airpods but the menu icon appears as the C-Command wand logo. In preferences I have tried clicking the icon with no luck. Thanks for any help

TF 2.4.9 (39)
El Capitan 10.11.6

Is the problem that nothing happens when you click the icon menu in the preferences? Or that you choose a new icon and it doesn’t stick? In any case, after clicking on the icon in the preferences, please send in a diagnostic report.

I was able to reproduce the problem, which seems to be due to an Xcode bug related to macOS 10.11. I’ll fix this in the next release of ToothFairy.

Wow thanks! (And icon changing is working normally on my MacBook running High Sierra)

This is fixed in ToothFairy 2.5.